Does the movie oversimplify the complex experience of intimate partner violence?
There’s no question that the idea of stopping domestic violence in its tracks is a great one.
However, anyone who has been through DV might be shocked at this presentation of its oversimplification.
Verywell Mind / Getty Images
This is their sordid story, with love triangle elements involving Lily’s first love.
This is minimized in the movie.
The book was written before revelations of DeGeneres being an abuser herself came to light.
In fact, the adaptation just kept the best of DeGeneres' work.
The adaptation also changed the book’s ending into a less harmful one.
In the book, abusive ex-husband Ryleco-parentswith Lily.
She adds that these phases are crucial to understanding the manipulation and confusion in domestic violence.
These phases are crucial to understanding the manipulation and confusion in domestic violence.
Why is this important?
Instead, everything seems perfectly fine whenever Ryle is not actively abusing Lily.
This provides a false sense of what the day-to-day experience of DV is actually like.
Schroeder, though, says that Lily may not have even realized initially that she was being abused.
Family Backgrounds Aren’t Always So Simple
In this story, Lily’s dad abuses her mom.
That standard,heteronormativeview of abuse is, outside of tired, not always the case.
Of the other 46%, only 51% were biological fathers to the children they abused.
While a lovely notion, it isn’t a terribly realistic one.
“In real life, getting that level of support can be much more complicated.”
For more mental health resources, see ourNational Helpline Database.
Friends and family of the person going through it might end up passing judgment and eventually distancing themselves."
Instead, Lily finds only complete support and encouragement from her peers.
That brings us to the next way that DV is portrayed inaccurately.
Good luck trying to leave as successfully and immediately as Lily did.
That just isn’t how it usually works.
And Do We Really Need to Sympathize With Abusers?
Lastly, Ryle is meant to be a character with whom we at least minimally sympathize.
He has a tragic backstory and he’s vaguely charming.
“Instead, they reinforced the belief that his trauma defined him and made him violent.
While trauma can be a reason for abusive behavior, it is never an excuse,” she adds.
ASPE.Male perpetrators of child maltreatment: findings from ncands.
2023;85(1):33-54.
